A recent investigation has revealed a significant challenge for websites relying on JavaScript to inject structured data: many AI crawlers cannot access this information. To ensure visibility in AI-driven search engines, web developers and SEO professionals must adopt alternative strategies like server-side rendering (SSR) or static HTML.

The Problem: AI Crawlers Can’t See JavaScript-Injected Data

Structured data, often formatted as JSON-LD, is crucial for search engine visibility. However, AI crawlers, including GPTBot (used by ChatGPT), ClaudeBot, and PerplexityBot, can only process the raw HTML response from the server. These crawlers do not execute JavaScript, making dynamically added structured data invisible to them.

This poses a major issue for websites using tools like Google Tag Manager (GTM) to inject JSON-LD on the client side. Key findings from Elie Berreby, founder of SEM King, highlight why this happens:

1. Initial HTML Load: AI crawlers receive only the raw HTML response from the server. If structured data is added via JavaScript, it is absent from this initial response.
2. Client-Side Execution: JavaScript executes in the browser and modifies the Document Object Model (DOM) for user interactions. Tools like GTM inject JSON-LD at this stage, but AI crawlers don’t render these changes.
3. No JavaScript Rendering: Many AI crawlers lack the capability to execute JavaScript, leaving them blind to client-side DOM updates. As a result, structured data added post-load remains invisible.

Why Googlebot Handles JavaScript Differently

Traditional search engines, like Google, have advanced JavaScript rendering capabilities. Googlebot can execute JavaScript and process DOM changes, including dynamically added JSON-LD data. This makes it more forgiving for JavaScript-heavy sites.

However, AI crawlers operate differently, focusing solely on the initial HTML response. This difference underscores the need for websites to adapt their structured data strategies for AI search engines.

Google’s Advice on JavaScript Overuse

Google has long warned about the risks of overusing JavaScript for essential SEO elements. In a recent podcast, Google’s Search Relations team emphasized the importance of balancing dynamic functionality with accessibility.

Martin Splitt, Google’s Search Developer Advocate, highlighted that while JavaScript is a powerful tool, it’s not always the best choice for critical content like structured data. John Mueller, another Search Advocate, advised developers to prioritize simpler, HTML-first solutions.

Solutions: Ensuring Structured Data Visibility

To address these challenges, developers and SEO professionals should adopt strategies that make structured data accessible to all crawlers, including those without JavaScript capabilities:

1. Server-Side Rendering (SSR): Render pages on the server so that structured data is included in the initial HTML response.
2. Static HTML: Embed schema markup directly in the HTML to eliminate reliance on JavaScript for essential content.
3. Prerendering: Use prerendered pages where JavaScript has been executed beforehand, delivering fully rendered HTML to crawlers.

These methods align with Google’s recommendations to prioritize HTML-first development, ensuring that critical content is present in the initial server response.

Why This Matters

AI crawlers are becoming increasingly important, and their inability to process JavaScript poses a risk to websites relying on client-side techniques for structured data. By shifting to server-side or static solutions, websites can maintain visibility in both traditional and AI-driven search engines.

If your site uses GTM or similar tools for client-side structured data injection, now is the time to adapt. Ensuring that your structured data is accessible to all crawlers will help you stay competitive in the evolving landscape of AI search.

If you’re still feeling overwhelmed or unsure, don’t worry—our monthly SEO packages are here to help. Let the experts take the reins and handle it for you!