Artificial intelligence has transformed content creation, offering both opportunities and challenges. On the positive side, AI can bring:

• Enhanced efficiency
• Innovative content ideas
• Faster research

These benefits enable SEO programs to work more quickly, save costs, add value, and sometimes increase revenue. Yet, AI content creation has its drawbacks, such as:

• Generic or bland content
• Low-quality writing
• Ineffective content

These issues can lead to poor user experiences, declining search rankings, or even deindexing from search results.

As AI content tools become more widespread, two different approaches have emerged for utilizing this technology:

1. The AI Enthusiasts: These individuals believe that you can generate content ready to publish almost instantly with the right AI tools. They see AI as a means to create large volumes of content quickly and efficiently.

2. The Traditionalists: This group maintains that AI is just a tool, and without human creativity and insight, AI-generated content lacks depth and expertise. They believe that human oversight is crucial to ensure quality and relevance.

I align with the second camp. While AI is evolving rapidly, and some claim you don’t need to edit AI-generated content before publishing, it’s more likely that this approach leads to content that gets published without getting caught, not necessarily content that ranks. After all, if it were that easy to rank, everyone would be at the top. The risk of poor-quality content ultimately falls on you.

Let’s explore these two schools of thought in greater detail to understand the best practices for AI content creation and how to strike a balance between technology and human expertise.

The Risks of an AI-Only Approach: Lessons from Brands That Moved Too Quickly

It’s no secret that AI tools are rapidly evolving, but relying solely on AI for content creation can lead to significant problems. Brands that jumped on the AI bandwagon without adequate oversight have experienced severe consequences—ranging from embarrassing PR incidents to total removal from Google search results.

Consider recent high-profile cases like MSN, Sports Illustrated, and others. These companies faced backlash after publishing either inaccurate, poorly written, or overly generic content. In some cases, it led to PR crises; in others, it resulted in deindexing during Google’s March 2024 updates.

Although it needs to be clarified which specific AI tools these brands used, one thing is evident: acting too quickly without a proper balance between AI and human review can lead to disastrous outcomes. While AI can offer immense efficiencies, it requires careful human oversight to ensure content quality and accuracy. With this, brands can retain their reputation and presence in search engine rankings.

The Collaborative Approach: Merging AI Tools with Human Expertise

If you’re looking for content that not only survives Google’s algorithms but also delivers real value to your audience while enjoying AI’s efficiency, you need a collaborative approach. This means combining:

• Professional writers and editors
• The right AI tools
• A robust content creation process

It might sound simple, but that’s the point. You shouldn’t remove human talent from your content projects. Instead, hire writers and editors who know how to use AI tools effectively, with discernment and creativity.

Here’s an example of how AI tools were used in creating this article:

• Brainstorming titles: AI helped generate a list of possible article titles, which sparked further ideas (though many were ultimately not used).
• Creating content outlines: AI-generated a content structure, with about half of the suggestions being helpful and the rest discarded.
• Summarizing existing content: AI summarized previously published material, providing valuable ideas to build on or expand.

To succeed with AI, remember this mantra: “Only quality content survives.” Here’s how you can make AI work within your collaborative process:

Produce Quality Content

• Create unique, user-focused content that builds trust and authority in your niche.
• Focus on providing helpful, people-first content that addresses your audience’s needs.
• Ensure your content offers something new and avoids a “copy/paste/reword” approach.

The Collaborative Content Creation Process

In my beginner’s guide to AI content creation, I detail a collaborative process that combines AI with human expertise. Here are some critical steps:

• Prework: Establish a solid framework for AI prompts, including the persona, target audience, tone, and content format.
• Content Creation: Use AI to generate ideas, create outlines, conduct research, and draft initial content. Note that AI-generated first drafts are just starting points; they require significant human refinement.
• Editing: Use AI detectors and plagiarism tools to ensure content integrity during editing. Fact-check all AI-generated statements, ensure the tone aligns with your brand, and correct any grammatical errors.

This approach requires time and effort but helps avoid AI’s pitfalls. Before adopting AI, evaluate whether it will save time and money in the long run. If not, reconsider your strategy.

By blending technology with human expertise, you can harness AI’s efficiency while maintaining high-quality content that meets your audience’s needs and survives search engine scrutiny.

The Balancing Act Between Automation and Collaboration

In the world of content creation, things are constantly in flux—Google’s algorithms evolve, and strategies adapt. Yet, amid these shifts, one constant remains: the need for high-quality content. The guidance I share today aligns with what I believe to be true for the foreseeable future, emphasizing a balanced approach between automation and collaboration.

AI tools can boost efficiency in content production, but they are merely that—tools. They are not standalone solutions. The key to sustainable content creation is integrating AI into the writer’s workflow, not replacing the writer entirely.

Here’s how to maintain this balance:

• Quality First: A robust content strategy prioritizes quality over quantity, regardless of how advanced AI becomes. This focus on quality will remain the bedrock of successful content strategies.
• Value for Your Audience: Content should offer genuine value to your readers, addressing their needs and interests. By doing so, you build a lasting connection that withstands algorithm changes.
• Adherence to Google’s Guidelines: Following Google’s best practices helps ensure that your content continues to rank well and isn’t penalized by algorithm updates. This means creating original, people-first content that contributes positively to the digital ecosystem.

The balancing act between automation and collaboration allows you to leverage AI’s efficiencies without sacrificing the human touch. Integrating AI into your process streamlines tasks like research and ideation, but the creative spark and editorial judgment still come from human expertise.

Ultimately, staying adaptable while remaining committed to quality is the key to long-term success. AI tools will evolve, but a collaborative approach—where technology supports rather than supplants human creativity—will always stand the test of time.

If you need more time to feel overwhelmed or confused, why not let the experts handle it? Explore our monthly SEO packages and let us do the heavy lifting. We’ll help you navigate the complexities of SEO so you can focus on what you do best.