Understand the Distinctions Between Search Marketing Generalists and Specialists. Explore How Both Roles Drive SEO and Paid Search Performance.

Search marketing is a distinctive facet of digital marketing because it involves many skills and requires individuals or teams to wear many hats to manage campaigns from start to finish effectively.

SEO, in particular, demands expertise beyond the conventional SEO role. Even paid search involves more than just handling ads on a search engine’s advertising platform. Experienced search marketers should comprehensively understand all elements involved in SEO and paid search. However, they often focus on the most enjoyable aspects, excel at, or have achieved notable success with.

For instance, an SEO professional might specialize in technical SEO, content-focused SEO, or even backlink strategies. Paid search experts may be adept at managing PPC campaigns, but they often require skills that overlap with other disciplines, such as UX design, copywriting, web development, and IT. Additionally, measurement and analytics require external support depending on the size and difficulties of the operation.

You have multiple options when building your in-house digital marketing team or selecting agencies and other partners to achieve your search marketing goals. Each choice comes with its own set of pros and cons. To ensure you choose the right partners or resources, it is crucial to evaluate your needs and match them with the expertise available. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, so you must understand your specific requirements and align them with the type of support you choose.

Take the time to weigh the pros and cons of both search marketing generalists and specialists. Consider their skill sets, approach to SEO and PPC, and the roles they can fulfill in your organization. Doing so lets you make an informed decision that best suits your search marketing needs and goals.

Search Marketing Generalists: Understanding the Role

A search marketing generalist is a professional or agency that handles a broad range of search marketing tasks. This can encompass SEO and paid search, with services covering everything from strategy development to tactical implementation, measurement, and analysis.

Pros of Generalists

• Streamlined Communication: A single point of contact reduces miscommunication and ensures a unified approach to search marketing.
• Brand Familiarity: Generalists often have a deeper understanding of your brand and its industry context, fostering more personalized strategies.
• Accountability: With one person or team handling all aspects of search marketing, there’s greater accountability for performance.

Cons of Generalists

• Limited Depth in Specialized Areas: Generalists may need more expertise in specialists focused on niche areas.
• Broad Focus: Strategy and implementation may be more big-picture, potentially needing more granular detail.
• Limited Experience in Specific Channels: Generalists might need hands-on experience with certain search platforms or cutting-edge techniques.

Generalists often bring a wealth of experience across various aspects of search marketing. If you’re considering hiring a generalist agency, they might offer a comprehensive suite of services, with SEO as one of many capabilities. While this broader focus is not necessarily a disadvantage, you should thoroughly evaluate their depth of knowledge in very specific areas relevant to your business.

Hiring a generalist offers advantages in terms of communication, a deeper connection with your business, and cost-effectiveness, particularly if they can manage a wide range of tasks without requiring additional resources. This can be appealing if you prefer a single point of contact or want to avoid juggling multiple agencies or specialists.

However, if your search marketing needs involve complex or highly specialized issues, a generalist might not be equipped to address them comprehensively. To ensure a good fit, conduct a thorough interview process and assess their track record in SEO and PPC. Verify that their experience and approach align with your expectations to avoid gaps in expertise or service delivery.

Search Marketing Specialists: An Overview

A search marketing specialist is a professional, team, or agency dedicated to a specific area of search marketing. This could be SEO or PPC, or even more specialized, such as focusing solely on technical SEO, content optimization, or advanced PPC strategies.

Pros of Specialists

• In-depth Expertise: Specialists offer deep knowledge and skills in specific areas of search marketing.
• Advanced Troubleshooting: Their focused expertise enables them to excel in diagnosing and resolving complex issues.
• Competitive Advantage: Specialists can help you stay ahead of competitors by applying advanced techniques and insights.

Cons of Specialists

• Less Business Integration: Specialists might need more attention to broader business objectives and strategies.
• Limited Scope: A specialist’s focus on a narrow area might mean they don’t cover other important aspects of search marketing.
• Higher Costs: Specialists can be more expensive, and you may need additional resources to cover broader needs.

A specialist can significantly enhance your search marketing efforts by offering deep insights and advanced problem-solving skills. Their expertise can lead to innovative strategies and give you an edge over competitors who might rely on generalists or less experienced teams.

However, their narrow focus might make it challenging for them to align with your overall business goals. They may also need more flexibility to manage a broader range of tasks or to contribute across different marketing disciplines. This could require hiring additional resources to fill the gaps, potentially increasing overall costs.

If you choose to work with a search marketing specialist, ensuring that their skills align with your specific needs is essential. Consider how well they can collaborate with other team members or agencies to create a cohesive search marketing strategy. This will help you make the most of their expertise while addressing any limitations in scope or integration with broader business objectives.

Conclusion

If you sense a bias in this article, that’s fine. But my intention was not to sway your opinion or overly emphasize the pros and cons of search marketing generalists versus specialists. Instead, I aimed to offer a balanced view so you can make an informed decision about what best suits your organization.

While I own a digital agency specializing in search, I can see both sides of the generalist versus specialist discussion. The line between the two isn’t always clear-cut, and that’s part of the beauty of the search marketing landscape.

Having started my career as an SEO professional when one person could handle most of the work, I’m pleased with the industry’s evolution toward more collaboration and integration. Search marketing has moved from being a niche to a core part of broader marketing strategies, and this change has brought both challenges and opportunities.

The key takeaway from this article is that there needs to be a single correct answer. Whether you’re building an in-house team, hiring an agency, or using a mix of approaches, you need to understand your resources, evaluate your strengths and weaknesses, and set realistic ROI expectations.

Given the proliferation of individuals and agencies claiming expertise in SEO and PPC, it’s crucial to thoroughly assess their capabilities and ensure they align with your company’s current needs and future goals. This will help you avoid missteps and ensure you’re investing in the right resources for your unique context. Ultimately, the best choice will depend on where you are as a business and where you want to go.

If you need help with SEO, consider exploring our monthly SEO packages and let our experts guide you. We offer professional support to help you navigate the complexities of SEO, ensuring your business achieves optimal visibility and success.