fbpx

Why Gemini Can’t Dethrone Google Search

4 min read

Google’s CEO, Sundar Pichai, recently addressed the future landscape of search, emphasizing the enduring significance of websites and search engines, which spells positive prospects for SEO practitioners. Simultaneously, he recognized the potential role of AI chatbots like Gemini. This acknowledgment might seem paradoxical, given the anticipation that AI could render traditional search engines obsolete. However, there’s a viable scenario where both entities coexist, evolving alongside each other in parallel trajectories.

 

Deciphering AI Search

 

In the discourse surrounding AI search, a crucial element often overlooked is the definition of AI search itself. It’s imperative to establish clarity because the concept encompasses three distinct paradigms:

  1. Search Engines: Traditional search platforms enhanced by AI technology operating in the background.
  2. Chatbots: These are represented by platforms like Gemini and ChatGPT, which facilitate conversational interactions driven by AI.
  3. Generative Search: This innovative approach integrates chatbots atop conventional search engines, as exemplified by initiatives such as Perplexity.ai and Bing, combining the strengths of both methodologies.

 

Redefining Search: Moving Beyond Traditional Notions

 

Description: The discussion surrounding traditional and organic search has remained unchanged for over two decades. However, it’s imperative to recognize that the landscape has evolved significantly. Traditional search no longer exists as we once knew it. With AI driving search processes from inception to completion, it’s time to shift our discourse away from traditional search and embrace the era of AI-powered search.

 

Embracing the Era of AI-Powered Search

 

Sundar Pichai emphasized Google’s extensive use of AI over the years, which is evident in systems like RankBrain, SpamBrain, and the Helpful Content System (HCU), among others. These AI-driven mechanisms detect fake reviews, optimize crawling and indexing processes, and influence ranking decisions. Google’s 2021 documentation on SpamBrain highlights AI’s role in identifying spam during crawling and indexing, preventing malicious content from entering the index.

Google’s recent March 2024 core algorithm update, described as intricate and ongoing, suggests a shift towards a more AI-centric infrastructure. This likely involves integrating AI signals from systems like the HCU and Reviews System directly into the core algorithm.

Despite concerns from SEOs about the eventual dominance of “AI search,” it’s crucial to recognize that Google has long provided question-answering capabilities through featured snippets and knowledge graph search results. In essence, Google is an AI-powered search engine, rendering traditional search obsolete.

Acknowledging this reality is vital, as it aligns with Sundar Pichai’s vision for the future of search over the next decade.

 

Redefining Search: Blended Hybrid Search as Generative Search

 

The term “AI Search” often fails to accurately capture the essence of the evolving landscape. A more fitting designation is Generative Search. Platforms like Bing and Perplexity.ai exemplify this concept, embodying generative AI chatbots integrated atop a search index. At the heart of this integration lies Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), a technology pioneered by Facebook AI researchers in 2020. RAG is the intermediary, facilitating seamless coordination between the chatbot and the search index, resulting in a blended hybrid search experience.

 

Exploring Chatbots

 

Chatbots encompass various entities, such as ChatGPT and Gemini. There’s no need to dwell on this aspect; let’s proceed.

 

Battle Royale: Search vs. Generative Search vs. Chatbots

 

Generative search presents an intriguing fusion of a chatbot and a search engine, sporting a cluttered interface. Its hybrid nature aims to assist with homework queries and local restaurant phone number searches but often needs to catch up in both areas. The question arises: does anyone genuinely desire a search engine capable of essay writing? These disjointed capabilities will eventually diminish, leading generative search to converge towards the established model embodied by Google.

 

Navigating the Future of Chatbots and Search Engines

 

In the foreseeable future, the landscape will be dominated by chatbots and search engines. Sam Altman has expressed concerns about an AI chatbot integrated with advertising, deeming it dystopian.

Google is pursuing a dual strategy by integrating the Gemini AI chatbot into Android as an AI assistant capable of making phone calls and providing restaurant recommendations. CEO Sundar Pichai has affirmed the importance of the web as a resource that Google intends to leverage.

However, the absence of ads in chatbots could significantly impact Google’s ad revenue. Despite this, the SEO industry remains convinced that AI will eventually supplant traditional search engines, potentially reshaping Google’s revenue sources towards cloud services and SaaS products if users transition to AI chatbots.

 

The Evolution of Query Deserves Advertising

 

In a realm where search advertising yields profits, it begs the question: why invest resources in web crawling and technology development without monetization? This contradiction contradicts Google’s ethos.

Enter Query Deserves Freshness, an algorithm that identifies trending or newsworthy search queries and prioritizes recently published fresh content.

Likewise, chatbots will discern when a query merits ads and seamlessly transition to search results. Google’s CEO, Sundar Pichai, refutes the narrative of search engine decline, emphasizing the necessity of web diversity for search’s future.

Google Search already furnishes ad-free answers for informational queries, like weather forecasts. For transactional searches, however, Query Deserves Advertising emerges as a solution.

As chatbots evolve, they may aptly recognize shopping queries as meriting ads, transitioning to search engine inventory inclusive of advertising. This aligns with Pichai’s vision of coexisting web and AI.

In essence, Query Deserves Advertising could safeguard search engines’ lucrative ad business amidst the AI era’s evolution.

 

Elevating Query Deserves Search

 

Expanding on this notion leads us to contemplate search queries necessitating human input: comparisons, user reviews, expert human reviews, news, medical, financial, and more. These queries may similarly transition to search results, albeit with a different appearance than current ones. Reviews, news, gossip, and other human-generated topics remain cherished by users, underlining the enduring importance of insights and personality in search results.

 

Rethinking SEO: Query Deserves Optimization

 

The knee-jerk reaction proclaiming the demise of SEO is premature. We’re merely scratching the surface of this evolution. As long as there’s profit potential in search, the demand for websites, search engines, and SEO will persist.

 

If you still find it all tricky and perplexing, why not explore our monthly SEO packages? Let our experts guide you through the process.

Shilpi Mathur
navyya.shilpi@gmail.com