The impact of search algorithm changes is hitting with the force of a Taylor Swift breakup anthem.

The discourse has been buzzing with discussions on core updates, the importance of helpful content, combating reputation abuse, and more. With OpenAI’s development of a search engine and the anticipated expansion of Google’s Search Generative Experience, staying abreast of these changes has become increasingly challenging, leaving many SEOs with a severe case of FOMO.

Amidst all this chatter, specific recurring themes emerge. While search engines are evolving rapidly, neither our conceptual understanding of search engines nor our approach to SEO has kept pace with this evolution.

With each new change, my initial instinct is to decipher the motives behind the search engines’ actions and their intended objectives. This can prove challenging, given that it often requires adopting a perspective that contrasts with that of a site owner or business.

Lately, I’ve found myself frequently assuming the role of a contrarian. I believe that sharing some unpopular opinions could offer valuable insights for many businesses, even if they may be difficult to accept.

1. SEO Transformed into Genuine Marketing As algorithms evolve, we’re veering away from gaming search engines and toward authentic marketing. Neglecting user needs, personas, and intent spells failure from the start. Too often, SEO strategies begin with “I have this thing. Make it rank for this keyword,” which is fundamentally flawed. A better approach starts with understanding user intent and crafting content accordingly.
2. Spam and Tricks: Not a Sustainable Model Every SEO, even those who champion white-hat tactics publicly, experiments with spammy techniques and “programmatic SEO.” However, relying on such tactics as a business model entails significant risks. While they might be acceptable for disposable affiliate sites, they’re unsuitable for businesses with employees dependent on stable revenue streams.
3. Search Engines Aren’t Obligated to Provide Traffic Search engines aren’t impartial entities; they serve their users’ interests above all else. Complaints about search engine biases often overlook that user behavior drives these biases. Google’s reliance on click data for training algorithms underscores the importance of building a recognizable brand—a feat requiring substantial time and effort.
4. Prioritize Search Users Over Business Interests Aligning with search engines’ user-centric approach is essential for success. Our marketing efforts must cater to user preferences and search engines’ interpretations of those preferences. As user preferences evolve, this requires flexibility and underscores the importance of maintaining a distinct business identity.
5. Diversify Search Results Beyond Websites The days of search engines merely indexing web pages are long gone. Users seek direct answers to queries, not convoluted web pages laden with intrusive elements. Bill Gates’ insight about the future of search being action-oriented resonates profoundly. Prioritizing websites that facilitate user tasks over those merely seeking to manipulate search rankings is critical.
6. Addressing Reputation Abuse Content promoted solely for monetary gain, regardless of its utility, risks being perceived as an ad by search engines. While such content may benefit your audience, its ranking depends on its perceived usefulness to the broader user base. While monetizing such content is feasible through other channels, only expect it to rank if it aligns with search engines’ criteria for usefulness.

Rethinking SEO: Embracing Change and Prioritizing User Intent

In the era of our Wildest Dreams, tactics like You Belong With Me SEO may have thrived. However, since the infamous Florida!!! Update, they’ve only fueled Bad Blood with search engines. Our current strategies resemble Fifteen-year-old Cardigans—comfortable but far from Timeless. It’s time to Shake It Off and let go of outdated methods.

Change is imperative. We must Speak Now with Fearless determination to understand user intent. Our efforts deserve more than trend-chasing. Let’s Begin Again by aligning with what search engines perceive as user needs rather than filling a Blank Space with content that misses the mark or Hits Differently than what users seek. This marks a new era, calling for a Long Live SEO strategy centered on user experience and trust-building. This is Nothing New. Long Story Short, it’s time for genuine marketing. Are you… Ready for It?

I sincerely apologize for the Taylor Swift-themed paragraphs. I couldn’t resist.

While this AI-augmented joke is amusing, it highlights why users prefer user-friendly, non-AI content like this paragraph.

Our next steps are clear: prioritize user and search engine intent—what they believe their users want. Additionally, it’s wise to diversify businesses to reduce dependence on a single traffic source.

Search engines—and their presentation of results—will evolve, but users will always have needs. As long as that’s the case, marketers will play a role in helping them make decisions and accomplish tasks.

Whether it’s SEO or marketing, Call It What You Want. 🙂

 If navigating this process feels overwhelming, consider exploring our monthly SEO packages and enlist the assistance of seasoned experts.